• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Oh, That's Good

menu icon
go to homepage
  • All Recipes
  • For Two
  • Collections
  • About
  • Tips
  • Appetizers
  • Soups
  • Cookies
  • Pies & Tarts
  • Cake & Muffins
  • Sides
  • Savory Breakfast
  • Sweet Breakfast
  • Pasta & Rice
  • Bread & Pastry
  • Ice Cream & Puddings
  • Beef
  • Poultry
  • Pork
  • Sandwich & Burger
  • Pizza
  • Sauce & Condiments
  • Asian
  • Mediterranean
  • Tex-Mex
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Pinterest
  • subscribe
    search icon
    Homepage link
    • All Recipes
    • For Two
    • Collections
    • About
    • Tips
    • Appetizers
    • Soups
    • Cookies
    • Pies & Tarts
    • Cake & Muffins
    • Sides
    • Savory Breakfast
    • Sweet Breakfast
    • Pasta & Rice
    • Bread & Pastry
    • Ice Cream & Puddings
    • Beef
    • Poultry
    • Pork
    • Sandwich & Burger
    • Pizza
    • Sauce & Condiments
    • Asian
    • Mediterranean
    • Tex-Mex
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Pinterest
  • ×
    HOME » Recipes » Sandwich & Burger

    Published: Mar 3, 2014 · Modified: Apr 9, 2021· This website generates income via ads · by Mary

    How to Cook Corned Beef for Reuben Sandwiches

    Jump to Recipe

    My favorite way to eat corned beef is in the delicious sandwich made famous by Reuben Kulakofsky, the Reuben sandwich. You don't need to wait for St. Patrick's Day, or even dinner time tonight, for a great Reuben sandwich. I am going to show you How to Cook Corned Beef for Reuben Sandwiches any time of the year. You can cook corned beef in a crock pot, instant pot, large skillet, or a large pot on the stove. I think slow braising in the oven is the best method for cooking corned beef for Reuben sandwiches.

    The real star of the original sandwich is the tender corned beef, but it would be nothing without my Reuben sauce recipe. Slather your beef sandwiches with it and serve extra in a small bowl for dipping. Don't think a jar of Russian dressing off the shelf will have the same result. You need to make the sauce!

    Now, let's get started making the corned beef for a classic Reuben sandwich to rival the best local deli.

    Corned beef sandwich cut in half with sauce and cheese oozing out.

    We seem to always think of Ireland when the subject of corned beef and cabbage comes up, but you might be surprised at the storied past of this dish. If you care to take a deep dive into the history of corned beef, I recommend this article in The New York Times.

    Jump to:
    • Ingredients
    • Substitutions
    • Variations of How to Cook Corned Beef for Reuben Sandwiches
    • Instructions
    • Please read the recipe update note in the green box regarding the steps for this recipe. Thanks!
    • How to Cook Corned Beef for Reuben Sandwiches
    • Comments

    Ingredients

    Ingredients for corned beef brisket.
    • Corned Beef Brisket with spice packet
      • The cut of meat used for corned beef is a beef roast referred to as a brisket. Corned beef differs from "brisket" in that it is salt-cured. Any size corned beef brisket will work except for very small briskets which might get too dry.
      • For homemade Reuben sandwiches, I prefer the cut referred to as the flat versus the point.
      • The flat is just that, flat. It cooks evenly and slices beautifully for Reuben sandwiches.
      • The point works well for long cooking in a slow cooker or boiling in a pot.
      • The meat from the point works best for shredding.
    • Dijon Mustard
      • Plain or grainy does not matter. The mustard adds a little extra flavor, but its primary job is to keep the spices in place.

    Substitutions

    I highly recommend making my Reuben Sauce recipe for the sandwich dressing. It is perfect. If you prefer, a good homemade Russian dressing or a homemade Thousand Island dressing will work. I have never found a jarred dressing that I think lives up to the best Reuben.

    Sandwich bread for a Reuben is, by tradition, slices of rye bread. I prefer Jewish rye or marble rye, the latter being the most difficult to find. Dill rye is delicious on a good Reuben too.

    Slices of Swiss cheese are traditional for Reubens. I love the way a slice of melted cheese, especially Swiss cheese, oozes out from between the slices of bread.

    Variations of How to Cook Corned Beef for Reuben Sandwiches

    The Rachel sandwich is one of several variations of the Reuben sandwich. Instead of the classic corned beef and sauerkraut, a Rachel sandwich is usually made with turkey or pastrami, and topped with coleslaw. The ingredients they share in common are Swiss cheese and rye bread.

    Instructions

    Steps 1-6: Rinsing the corned beef.

    Corned beef in the package.
    Remove brisket from package.
    Wire rack in sink.
    Wire rack placed in sink.
    Wire rack with corned beef and spice packet in sink.
    Brisket on rack with spice packet.
    Corned beef on wire rack in sink.
    Spice packet removed.
    Water spraying down on corned beef in sink.
    Rinsing with cold water.
    Rinsed corned beef brisket.
    Rinsed brisket with fat cap intact.
    • Remove brisket from package. I highly recommend doing so in the sink.
    • Place a wire rack in the sink.
    • Remove spice packet. Rinse the juices from the spice packet and set aside.
    • Turn on the cold water.
    • Lay the brisket on the wire rack. Thoroughly rinse the brisket in cold running water. Turn the brisket over and repeat.
    • Pat dry, leaving the fat cap intact.

    Steps 7-12: Prepping the corned beef.

    Meaty side of corned beef and spice packet.
    Trim any connective tissue.
    Fat cap side of corned beef with spice packet.
    Leave fat cap intact.
    Spreading coarse mustard on corned beef.
    Brush fat cap with Dijon mustard.
    Spreading mustard on meaty side of corned beef.
    Brush second side with Dijon mustard.
    Sprinkling contents of spice on meaty side of corned beef.
    Speckle spices on both sides.
    Spice packet contents on fat cap side of brisket.
    Place in baking dish with ½" water in bottom.
    • Remove the brisket from the sink. Trim off any connective tissue on the flesh side.
    • Leave the fat cap intact.
    • Brush the fat cap side with Dijon mustard.
    • Brush the flesh side with Dijon mustard.
    • Sprinkle the spices from the packet on both sides.
    • Place the brisket in a baking pan. Add a little water to come up about ½" in the baking dish.

    Steps 13-21: Braising the corned beef.

    Baking dish covered with foil.
    Cover with foil and bake at 320 degrees for 2 hours.
    Thermometer into cooked corned beef.
    Check the internal temperature of the corned beef.
    Cooked corned beef in baking dish.
    Score the meat with a sharp knife to prevent curling.
    Fat cap removed from corned beef.
    Flip the meat with the fat cap down, cover with foil and return to oven.
    Meaty side of corned beef in baking dish.
    Remove from oven when tender and discard liquid.
    Scored corned beef brisket.
    Use a sharp knife to remove the fat cap.
    Scored piece of corned beef.
    Taste the meal for saltiness.
    Corned beef with score marks.
    If meat is too salty proceed to next step.
    Corned beef in a shallow pan with water.
    If meat is too salty, add to a pot of simmering water for 5 minutes.
    Sliced corned beef on cutting board.
    Taste again. If perfect, allow to cool and slice against the grain.
    • Cover with aluminum foil and bake at 320 degrees for two hours.
    • Remove the meat and check the internal temperature. Corned beef must be at least 145 degrees for safe eating, but collagen and fat do not begin to dissolve until the temp reaches 190 degrees. The meat is safe to eat but needs more time to tenderize. Mine is at 202 degrees and is starting to get tender, but needs more braising time.
    • At this time you may find that the fat cap is beginning to shrink, causing the meat to curl. Use a sharp knife to cut through the fat cap from side to side in a couple of places. This should release the fat, allowing the beef to maintain a flat shape. Keep the fat cap in place, just score it. You will remove it later but for now, it will keep the meat from drying out.
    • Flip the meat with the fat cap down, cover it with foil, and return to the oven. Continue checking for desired tenderness every 10-15 minutes.
    • Remove from oven to a cutting board when tender and discard liquid.
    • Use a sharp knife to remove the fat cap. Discard the fat cap.
    • Cut a small piece of meat off the end and taste for saltiness. Oftentimes the meat will be too salty for your liking at this point. The saltiness of corned beef varies from supplier to supplier, but it is an easy fix if it is too salty.
    • Bring enough water to almost cover the corned beef to a slow boil in a saucepan over medium heat. Place the corned beef in the simmering water and reduce heat to medium-low heat for 5 minutes. Take the meat out and taste it again. If it is still too salty, return it for another five minutes. I generally ask my hubby for a second opinion at this point.
    • If perfect, allow to cool before slicing. Notice the way the grain of the meat runs in the last picture? You will see that when I slice it, I slice it against the grain, not in the same direction in the grain. This is the secret to juicy, tender corned beef.
    Direction for properly slicing corned beef.

    Please read the recipe update note in the green box regarding the steps for this recipe. Thanks!

    Corned beef sandwich with a bite taken out.

    How to Cook Corned Beef for Reuben Sandwiches

    Oven-braising is a great way to cook corned beef for the classic Reuben sandwich without boiling out all the flavor.
    4.62 from 116 votes
    Print Recipe Pin Recipe
    Prep Time 20 minutes mins
    Cook Time 3 hours hrs
    Course
    Sandwich
    Servings 4 sandwiches
    Budget
    Frugal

    Equipment

    • Wire rack
    • Paper towels
    • Small brush
    • Sharp knife
    • 9x11 baking pan
    • Large skillet.

    Ingredients
      

    • 3.5 pounds corned beef brisket with spice packet
    • 1 tablespoon Dijon mustard regular or grainy
    • Water

    Instructions
     

    Prepare corned beef

    • Remove brisket from package in the sink. Place a wire rack in sink.
    • Remove spice packet. Rinse the juices from the spice packet and set aside. Turn on cold water.
    • Lay the brisket on the wire rack. Thoroughly rinse brisket in cold running water. Turn the brisket over and repeat.
    • Pat dry, leaving fat cap intact.

    Prepping the corned beef

    • Remove brisket from sink. Trim off any connective tissue on flesh side.
    • Leave the fat cap intact. and brush that side with Dijon mustard.
    • Turn the brisket over and brush the flesh side with Dijon mustard.
    • Sprinkle the spices from the packet on both sides.
    • Place the brisket in a baking pan. I used a 9x11 glass baking dish. Add a little water to come up about ½" in the baking dish.

    Braising the corned beef

    • Cover with aluminum foil and bake at 320 degrees for two hours.
    • Remove the meat and check the internal temperature. Corned beef must be at least 145 degrees for safe eating, but collagen and fat do not begin to dissolve until the temp reaches 190 degrees. The meat is safe to eat, but needs more time to tenderize.
    • At this time you may find that the fat cap is beginning to shrink, causing the meat to curl. Use a sharp knife to cut through the fat cap from side to side in a couple of places. This should release the fat, allowing the beef to maintain a flat shape. Keep the fat cap in place, just score it. You will remove it later but for now it will keep the meat from drying out.
      Cooked corned beef in baking dish.
    • Flip the meat with the fat cap down, cover with foil and return to oven. Continue checking for desired tenderness every 10-15 minutes.
    • Remove from oven to a cutting board when tender and discard liquid.
    • Use a sharp knife to remove the fat cap. Discard the fat cap.
    • Cut a small piece of meat off the end and taste for saltiness. Oftentimes the meat will be too salty for your liking at this point.
    • If the meat is too salty, bring enough water to almost cover the corned beef to a slow boil in a saucepan over medium heat. Place the corned beef in simmering water for 5 minutes. Take the meat out and taste again. If it is still too salty, return it for another five minutes.
    • If perfect, allow to cool before slicing. To get perfect tender slices you need to slice AGAINST the grain of the meat.
    • Notice the way the grain of the meat runs in the picture. You will see that when I slice it, I slice it against the grain, not in the direction of the grain. 
      Direction for properly slicing corned beef.

    Making the Reuben

    • Butter one side of each slice of bread and place it, butter side down, in a skillet over medium-low heat.
    • Cover one side with a slice to two of Swiss cheese and the other side with the sliced corned beef. Pile it as high as you like.
    • When the cheese melts and the meat heated through remove from heat. Top with my Reuben Sauce or Russian dressing. You can add sauerkraut or coleslaw if you like or serve them on the side. Lay a spear of kosher dill pickle alongside the sandwich and serve hot.

    Notes

     
    Nutritional Note: The nutritional data is calculated the cooked weight of the meat which is slightly more than half the raw weight. The bread, condiments, and cheese are NOT included in the calculation due to personal preference variables.
     
    My Reuben Sauce Recipe

    Nutrition

    Serving: 1sandwichCalories: 451kcalCarbohydrates: 1gProtein: 33gFat: 34gSaturated Fat: 11gPolyunsaturated Fat: 1gMonounsaturated Fat: 16gCholesterol: 122mgSodium: 2801mgPotassium: 679mgFiber: 1gSugar: 1gVitamin A: 3IUVitamin C: 61mgCalcium: 18mgIron: 4mg

    Approximate nutrition information is provided as a convenience and courtesy only. You are encouraged to do your own calculations if precise data is required.

    We take every effort to ensure that the estimated meal cost per serving is accurate. We use a meal cost analysis application that estimates the cost of a recipe based on groceries purchased at a Walmart store in my geographical area, northern California.

     
    Nutritional Note: The nutritional data is calculated the cooked weight of the meat which is slightly more than half the raw weight. The bread, condiments, and cheese are NOT included in the calculation due to personal preference variables.
     
    My Reuben Sauce Recipe
    Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

    More Sandwich & Burger

    • A person holding a fried green tomato sandwich on a tray.
      Fried Green Tomato Grilled Cheese Sandwich
    • Grilled cheese and sliced pear sandwich.
      Grilled Cheese with Pear
    • Bao bun with Asian style beef, cilantro, and hot sauce.
      Spicy Beef Bao
    • Wooden board with a wedge of muffuletta sandwich and caper berries.
      Muffuletta Sandwich

    Sharing is caring! Thanks for supporting us!

    583 shares
    • Facebook
    • Email

    Reader Interactions

    Comments

      Comment Cancel reply

      Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

      Recipe Rating




    1. KS says

      March 22, 2023 at 8:16 pm

      5 stars
      Oh, spot ON! This recipe worked perfectly, as-is. However, I had cooked it in the oven for less time than called for (since it was smaller: a 2-1/2lb brisket), and poured the water out after an hour. Realizing it still needed more oven braising, I redid adding the water. The end result was much less salty - so I didn't even need the last (stove-top) step anyway. Thank you for making me feel like a pro when making this my 1st time. My family LOVED it!

      Reply
      • Mary says

        March 22, 2023 at 11:21 pm

        I am so glad it worked for you! You’re a pro now! I always buy the same store brand of corned beef but this year’s was super salty. Thanks so much for your kind comment!

        Reply
    2. Lea Ann (Cooking On The Ranch) says

      March 09, 2014 at 8:13 am

      I am so ready for a corned beef sandwich and this year it's going to be this one. I love the sound of that sauce .... and why have I never cooked my corned beef in ale? Love everything about this. Pinned.

      Reply
      • Mary says

        March 09, 2014 at 8:17 am

        Thanks Lea Ann. I prefer a pale ale to a dark for the corned beef. Hope you like it!

        Reply

    Primary Sidebar

    A woman wearing a vintage 1949 t - shirt.

    I am Mary, the blogger behind "Oh That's Good!" I live with my husband, Michael and our little mutt, Lucky in a lovely retirement community in northern California. We are cooking for two, without breaking the bank!

    more about

    Footer

    ↑ back to top

    • Privacy Policy
    • Nutritional Disclaimer
    • Contact
    • Work With Me