Reuben Sauce Recipe

My Reuben Sauce Recipe is a very good thing to dress the slices of rye bread on Reuben sandwiches. The classic Reuben sandwich is a New York City staple, originating from the Blackstone Hotel. A masterpiece of corned beef, Swiss cheese, tangy sauerkraut, and creamy Russian dressing, all sandwiched between two slices of rye bread. And while the sandwich is divine, it’s the homemade Russian dressing that really brings all the flavors together. This sauce is perfect on my Reuben Sandwich.

WHAT’S SO GOOD ABOUT THIS RECIPE?

This Reuben sauce recipe captures the essence of a classic Reuben sandwich in all its glory. Straight from the bustling streets of New York City to your kitchen, the sauce is flavorful in every bite. The blend of ingredients creates a tangy flavor that perfectly complements the layers of corned beef and melted Swiss cheese. Its rich, velvety texture clings to every inch of rye bread, ensuring every bite is a delightful mix of the sauce and sandwich fillings.

Unlike the traditional Thousand Island dressing, our sauce boasts a depth of flavor, elevating it from just another dressing to a star in its own right. Each component, from the grated onion to the dash of Hungarian paprika, plays a crucial role in delivering an unparalleled taste. It’s a versatile recipe; not only does it make Reuben sandwiches irresistibly good, but it’s also a fantastic addition to various dishes needing a creamy, tangy boost. Think of this sauce as an ode to the best Reuben sandwiches you've ever had—a homage to the rich culinary traditions of New York City. With this recipe in your collection, every meal can have a touch of that classic Reuben magic.

IS THIS RECIPE BUDGET-FRIENDLY

Yes, this Reuben sauce recipe fits the "cheap" category on my blog. Creating a flavor-packed sauce doesn’t have to be expensive. And trust me, all my recipes are good!

INGREDIENTS FOR MY REUBEN SAUCE RECIPE

Using the best quality ingredients will make the best Reuben sauce!

Exact quantities and measurements can be found in the recipe card.

INGREDIENT NOTES

• Prepared horseradish: Adds that characteristic tangy kick. Use what you like, prepared or cream style. Use more or less to taste. I like to use prepared, not cream style because it packs more of a punch, and makes for a more delicious sandwich, which we like.
• Grated onion: Essential for a burst of fresh flavor. Don't skip the juice—it contributes to the sauce's texture and richness. You will be grating the onion and using the juice as well. The juice really makes it very tasty.
• Worcestershire sauce: A secret ingredient that deepens the sauce's taste.
• Hungarian paprika: Opt for either sweet or hot, depending on your preference. I use Sweet Hungarian Paprika.
• Celery seed: Always add that familiar flavor to the classic Reuben sandwich recipe.
• Mayonnaise: Use good mayonnaise for this, not lite mayo or Miracle Whip.

SUBSTITUTIONS

• Ketchup: Can substitute with chili sauce for a spicier kick.
• Horseradish: Dijon mustard can be a backup, but it will change the flavor profile. You could also add hot sauce and sour cream if you don't like horseradish.
• Celery seed: A dash of hot sauce could do if you're out of celery seed.

VARIATIONS

• Rachel sandwich style: Swap the corned beef for turkey and you'll need this sauce! This is the turkey version of a good Reuben!
• With a twist: Introduce pickle relish for an added dimension of taste. Some people like to add sweet pickle relish, chopped dill pickles, or Dijon mustard.

EQUIPMENT

A small bowl and a whisk or spatula are essential. Store your sauce in a jar, ready to serve alongside some potato chips or french fries. This dressing makes the best sauce for dipping fries or chips.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

PRO COOKING TIPS

• If you're spreading this on slices of rye bread for a Reuben sandwich, do so on the side of each slice of bread to ensure every bite is flavorful.
• Ensure your sauce is at room temperature when spreading it on a slice of bread, especially if you’re planning on toasting or grilling.