How to Cook Oysters on the Grill with Garlic Butter

There's an old saying that goes, "The world is your oyster." And what better way to enjoy this world than with a delectable oyster recipe, cooked on a hot grill, doused in garlic butter? Oysters have always been a delicacy, and How to Cook Oysters on the Grill with Garlic Butter method of grilling them brings out their natural, briny flavor while adding the savory richness of garlic butter.

Three grilled oysters with parmesan and garlic butter on a plate with a lettuce wedge salad.

Jump to:

WHAT'S SO GOOD ABOUT THIS RECIPE?
IS THIS RECIPE BUDGET-FRIENDLY?
INGREDIENTS
INGREDIENT NOTES
STEP-BY-STEP INSTRUCTIONS
SUBSTITUTIONS
VARIATIONS
EQUIPMENT
PRO COOKING TIPS
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Great recipe for a lazy weekend.
Grilled Oysters with Parmesan Garlic Butter
If you enjoyed Grilling Oysters...Try this Grilled Branzino!
Comments

WHAT'S SO GOOD ABOUT THIS RECIPE?

When it comes to oyster recipes, the combination of fresh oysters, garlic butter, and the smoky touch from the grill is unparalleled. While many indulge in raw oysters, there's something comforting and warming about chargrilled oysters. The butter mixture seeps into the oyster meat, resulting in a burst of flavors with each bite. And trust me, the outcome is so good, you'll find it hard to stop at just one.

IS THIS RECIPE BUDGET-FRIENDLY?

While this grilled oyster recipe falls under the "splurge" category on ohthatsgood.com, the luxurious taste and experience it offers are worth every penny. The oysters in these photos cost $1.79 each at a new food co-op in town. You can usually find them for about $1.00 each. Then with just a little white wine, you can elevate this dish even further without going overboard on the budget.

INGREDIENTS

For the full recipe with quantities, see the recipe card at the end of the post.

INGREDIENT NOTES

Fresh oysters: Always opt for high-quality oysters like those from Hog Island Oyster Company or any other renowned source in the United States. Remember, fresh oysters will have a sealed, flat side.
Butter: While the recipe calls for standard butter, using a small saucepan, you can clarify it to remove any impurities. This gives your butter sauce a clear, golden look.
Garlic: Fresh garlic is key. It brings out the flavor in the butter mixture, enhancing the overall taste.

STEP-BY-STEP INSTRUCTIONS

Fresh scrubbed raw oysters in the shell.

STEP 1: Wash and scrub the oysters in cold running water, removing any sand, mud or loose shell. Place the clean oysters in a big bowl and keep refrigerated until ready to use.

Bowl with butter, parsley, garlic, and Parmesan cheese.

STEP 2: Add the softened butter, grated garlic, chopped parsley, Parmesan cheese to a bowl. Salt is not needed because the oysters are already salty.

A bowl of garlic butter with a spoon in it.

STEP 3: Mix the garlic butter until well incorporated and set aside at room temperature.

Oysters are being grilled outdoors on a grill.

STEP 4: Heat a grill to high heat. Remove oysters from the bowl and place on the grill using tongs.

A person holding a grilled oyster after shucking.

STEP 5: Grill the oysters until they pop open a little bit. Remove from the heat with the tongs, and use an oyster shucker to pry and twist the oyster apart.

A person is grilling oysters adding butter.

STEP 6: Place the butter mixture over the oysters with a spoon, dividing it equally.

STEP 7: Grill the oysters until the butter mixture melts.

Person squeezing lemon juice over oysters on the grill.

STEP 8: Squeeze lemon juice over the oysters on the grill.

A person adding hot sauce to oysters on the grill.

STEP 9: Add a few drops of hot sauce to each oyster. (optional)

Grilled oysters with charred shells and crispy edges..

STEP 10: Continue grilling the oysters as the liquid is reduced.

STEP 11: Use your tongs to keep the oysters upright.

Grilled oysters with Parmesan. and hot sauce.

STEP 12: Continue cooking the oysters until their "liquor" has burned off, leaving just the butter and cheese. They should be lightly golden brown.

SUBSTITUTIONS

Olive oil: If you're not a fan of melted butter, a drizzle of olive oil can be a great alternative.
Lemon wedges: You can use a little lemon juice instead of hot sauce for a tangy kick.

VARIATIONS

White wine: A splash of white wine in the butter mixture can add a sophisticated flavor profile.
New Orleans style: To get a New Orleans twist, you can add some rock salt and crusty French bread on the side.

EQUIPMENT

Having the right equipment is crucial for grilling oysters. Key items include a large bowl, scrubbing brush, oyster shucker, and microwave. You'll also need tongs - the longer, the better - for safely flipping the oysters on the grill grates. Using a gas grill or charcoal grill is up to your preference, though each gives a slightly different smoky touch. Lastly, a serving platter is essential to present your creation beautifully.

PRO COOKING TIPS

Always use a real oyster shucker, not a sharp knife. The tip of the oyster knife is specially designed to safely open the top shell.

Fresh oysters with an oyster shucker on a small box.

When grilling oysters, the bottom shell tends to get hotter. So, always use an oven mitt or potholder for safety.
When the shells pop open on the hot grill, that's your cue! It's the perfect time to add the butter sauce.
I like to serve grilled oysters on a bed of coarse salt. It helps to stabilize the oysters so the butter does not spill. When I took this photo I had Hawaiian black sea salt on hand and I used it. I love the drama it creates, but not necessary for just me and hubby.

Grilled Oyster on a bed of coarse black salt.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Can I use a food processor for the butter mixture?

Yes, a small bowl in a food processor will make mixing the ingredients a breeze. It might be more of a chore to wash the food processor than to just chop the ingredients and mix the compound butter by hand.

How do I know when the oysters are done on the grill?

After the oyster shells pop, and the oyster meat looks golden with the butter mixture, they're ready.

Can I grill oysters for the first time without any experience?

Absolutely. Just follow the recipe closely, especially the last step, and you'll be a pro in no time.

What is the adductor muscle of an oyster and am I supposed to eat it?

Oysters have an adductor muscle they flex the muscle to keep the shell closed. You can see the adductor muscle in the picture of eaten oysters below. The adductor muscle is firmly attached to the walls of oysters this large. It can be attached to either side of the shell. The oyster meat pulls easily off the muscle for eating. Never eat the adductor muscle as it is chewy and tough.

Great recipe for a lazy weekend.

Sticky Lemon Marmalade Chicken

Get the recipe →

Grilled oysters with lettuce and sour cream.

Grilled Oysters with Parmesan Garlic Butter

Hot grilled oysters with garlic and butter. No better way to eat oysters.

print PIN

Prep Time: 20

Cook Time: 18

Total Time: 38

Course: Main Course

Cuisine: American

Budget: Splurge

Calories: 653kcal

Servings:

Equipment

Large bowl
Scrubbing brush
Oyster shucker
Microwave
Tongs The longer, the better
Serving platter

Ingredients

12 large fresh oysters in the shell about 12 oysters
6 ounces butter
3 large cloves garlic finely minced or pressed
1 tablespoon chopped fresh parsley
3 tablespoons grated Parmesan cheese
Freshly ground black pepper to taste

Instructions

Wash and scrub the oysters in cold running water, removing any sand, mud or loose shell. Place the clean oysters in a big bowl and keep refrigerated until ready to use ( the same day). Do not cover with plastic wrap! Use a clean dishtowel to cover the bowl.
Soften the butter by leaving it out at room temperature. You can also do this in the microwave. Time varies, but mine takes about 10 seconds. Don't melt the butter. I have learned through experience that pouring melted butter onto an oyster on a hot grill will get your arms splattered with hot butter.
Put the butter in a medium bowl.
Add the garlic, cheese, parsley, and pepper. Salt is not needed because the oysters are already salty.
Heat an outdoor grill to high heat. I use propane but charcoal grilling works well too. I would never attempt this on an indoor grill due to the amount of smoke you get.
Remove the clean oysters from the bowl and place on the grill using tongs. Place them with the flattest side of the shell down. Discard any oysters that are already open! Never eat opened mollusks! You want them to be tightly closed.
Grill the oysters until they pop open a little bit. Remove from the heat with the tongs, and use an oyster shucker to pry and twist the oyster apart.
Careful, it's HOT! Shucking oysters can be dangerous, so never use a sharp knife. Use heat proof gloves or potholders to handle the oysters.
Save the half of shell that contains the oyster. Put it back on the hot grill. Discard the other side of the shell.
Place the butter mixture over the oysters with a spoon, dividing it equally.
Add a couple drops of hot sauce if you like or wait and add it at the table.
Continue cooking the oysters until their "liquor" has burned off, leaving just the butter and cheese. They should be lightly golden brown.
Don't overcook the oysters or they will be rubbery. Be careful when cooking oysters with butter. There is a lot of spitting and sputtering.
Remove the oysters with the tongs to a serving platter. Keep the oysters upright so you don't lose any of the delicious garlic butter.
Optional: You can add more Parmesan cheese after removing the oysters from the hot grill.
Enjoy piping hot with a dash of hot sauce if you like.

Nutrition

Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Grilling oysters for the first time can seem daunting, but with this recipe in hand, you're set for success. From the delightful garlic butter to the smoky essence from the grill, every element plays a part in creating an unforgettable dish. So, the next time you're looking to impress or just treat yourself, place oysters on your hot grill, follow this guide, and enjoy a luxurious meal that won't break the bank. Remember, life is too short for mediocre food, so always go for the best. And with this oyster recipe, "the best" is precisely what you're getting.

If you are fortunate enough to get your hands on some Bluepoint Oysters you must try my Grilled Bluepoint Oyster recipe. They have a similar compound butter but they grilling instructions are a bit different.

If you enjoyed Grilling Oysters...Try this Grilled Branzino!